Thursday, October 25, 2007

Looking Backward 2007 Best of BTFFL Draft

Honorable mentions


Adrian Arrington, 8th round, Halifax Spitfires. Good pick, decent value.

Ryan Mallett, 12th Round, Fighting Farmers. Mallett has been pressed into action and has performed reasonably as a Freshman. No doubt he will be Michigan’s starting QB in 2008.

And to the list:

10. Duane Bennett, 5th Round, Halifax Spitfires. The first of 4 Gophers to appear on this list, Bennett certainly appears set to be the Gophers RB next season. As a freshman he has been impressive, might have even taken over the starting position if not for injury.

9. Kory Sheets, Omar Conteh, and Evan Royster, 6th, 11th and 17th Rounds, Halifax Spitfires, Golden Goblins and Golden Goblins. This trio of Running Backs have one thing in common, the starters in front of them have been injured or lost the job for other reasons, they have all stepped in and played well. There is a bit of luck in these three but nonetheless, they have all paid dividends. They are the 9th, 8th and 16th ranked Running Backs as of this week.

8. James Hardy, 2nd Round, Golden Goblins. I hate to put high picks on this list but it always seems like one or two picks deserve it. And Hardy deserves it as he is the highest scoring WR in the League and the Goblins snatched him back with their first pick in the draft. Lucky thing Austin Scott was not available or the Goblins would be even worse.

7. CJ Bacher, 8th Round, Bucky’s Goodgers. The Goodgers only pick on this list. Bacher has outplayed Christiansen (5th), Boeckmann (6th), Hoyer (7th), and Henne (8th), all selected before him. Eighth QB off the board, third highest scorer. Goblins agonized between Bacher and Kinlaw – choose Kinlaw.

6. Javon Ringer, 4th Round, Golden Goblins. Ringer has been fantastic this season. He is the 4th highest scoring Running Back behind only Hill, Mendenhall and Hart – all three were keepers. He was also the 4th RB selected! Somehow, Scott, Taylor (inj) and Pinnix picked before Ringer.

5. Ernie Wheelwright, 10th Round, Golden Goblins. Another Gopher. Wheelwright has been a reliable BTFFL WR this year. He’s the 6th highest scoring WR and is outplaying a boatload of WRs selected ahead of him, including Benn (3rd), Bulter (6th), Beckum (7th), Brodell (7th), Arrington (8th) and Orton (10th).

4. Brian Robiski, 9th Round, Fightin’ Farmers. Robiski has been fantastic. Taken just one round before Wheelwright, selected after the mediocre group of WR, he is the 4th highest scoring WR.

3. Jehuu Caulcrick, 10th Round, Fightin’ Farmers. 5th Highest scoring RB, even after last week’s goose egg! Nonfactors like Austin Scott, Damien Sims, John Clay, Marcus Thigpen, and Brandon Saine selected ahead of him.

2. Eric Decker, 13th Round, Fightin’ Farmers. Go Gophers! Decker is the 7th highest scoring wide receiver in the BTFFL and he was picked after such duds as Butler, Brodell, Orton, Williams, Hubbard and Lymon.

1. Adam Weber, 5th Round, Fightin’ Farmers. Wow! The Farmers have the top 4 best picks in the draft and it looks like they are headed to the Blue Ox Bowl because of it. Weber, along with every other Gopher drafted was scoffed at by this author. How much crow can one man eat? Weber is the 2nd highest scoring QB (was 1 for much of the season) and is the biggest beneficiary of Brewster’s spread coast offense – although clearly not the only one. I guess he’s a keeper?

3 comments:

MarxistGopher said...

Looks like the Spitfires had the worst draft....outside of the 5 keepers, which are my entire team.

Jay said...

Not really -- it's just that you didn't have many great picks ... Your 5th, 6th, and 7th Round picks are all on the list or close. It's pretty close, I'd say between Matt and I as to who had a worse draft. Matt had the advantage of early picks, Hardy and Ringer, before I could even have picked (and damn it, I know I liked Ringer more than anyone in that damn draft room). Neither of us did well in the mid rounds. The only players that are playing on my team from the draft are Bacher (8th) and Mahlhoff (14th)(Carlos Brown just got a spot start). For MAtt, he's been forced to play Christensen all year, but also picked Kinlaw, Wheelwright, Conteh and Royster.

So I guess it isn't close -- I had the worst draft.

Jay said...

Kinlaw should be in here ... 8th Round, GG. 7th highest scoring RB.